What's in a building's name? | The Enterprise
SearchHelpSubscribe / renew
LoginCreate account

OPINION

What's in a building's name?

Posted on April 3, 2021

Updated on April 6, 2021

OpinionColumns

Tom Campbell

Tom Campbell

Be there anyone among us who leads or has led such a pure and exemplary life that he or she should be honored with his or her name on a building at our flagship university?

UNC Chapel Hill officials have sent out word they would like suggestions for renaming three buildings on their campus that will replace Aycock Residence Hall, named after former Gov. Charles B. Aycock, the Daniels Building, named for News & Observer publisher Josephus Daniels, and the Carr Building, named after industrialist Julian Carr. All three held racist viewpoints.

Today, most all of us find these positions repulsive and wrong, and it is understandable why many find their names on buildings offensive. We cannot ignore their beliefs, but neither should we ignore significant contributions they made.

Aycock built more public schools and libraries in his four years than any governor before or since and is still considered our “education governor.”

Josephus Daniels was U.S. secretary of the Navy in World War I and ambassador to Mexico.

Carr not only accumulated great wealth but was credited with helping a struggling Trinity College survive financial crisis. He then contributed the 300 acres of land that helped move the school to Durham and rename it. We know it as Duke University.

Racism is America’s “original sin,” but it is not our only sin.

This whole topic begs the question whether we should name any public buildings after people. There are few among us who have never had any blot on their moral character; this is most especially true for those who have accumulated great wealth or have made significant accomplishments in their lives — those who we might usually consider honoring with their name on a building.

In the philanthropic world, you quickly learn that one of the best ways to get someone to make a sizeable financial contribution to your cause is to promise to name a building, school or program in his or her name. The Morehead and Park scholarships at Carolina and N.C. State quickly come to mind and prove the point.

What are the criteria we should use to decide? What is a significant enough contribution (financially or otherwise) to be a determinant?

Is the naming a forever decision or perhaps an honor to last for a time certain, like 20 years? And who is really qualified to make such significant decisions? In the case of a public institution like one of our universities, just how diverse and representative should the decision-making body be?

If we take racism (or any “-ism”) off the list of criteria, there’s not much left. Maybe we should just give them names of trees or flowers or animals. Or perhaps we might be best served to just number them, but then we have to keep buildings in some kind of numerical sequence, don’t we? It would be maddening for building 1201 to be on one side of a campus and 1202 on the opposite side.

This whole topic has opened a can of worms. Who would want to reside or go to class in a building named for a parasite?

Tom Campbell is a North Carolina Hall of Fame broadcaster and columnist who has covered North Carolina public policy issues since 1965. He recently retired from writing, producing and moderating the statewide half-hour TV program “N.C. Spin” that aired 22 ½ years. Contact him at tomcamp@carolinabroadcasting.com. 

Related content

In praise of pizzerias: Comfort by the slice

While you wouldn’t necessarily think so, there are few things more American than the local pizza pla...

Was popping mileage fee balloon a good idea?

There’s a concept in politics called a “trial balloon.” It’s a way to test the support for a policy ...

Never a better time to invest in NC

North Carolina is poised to make great gains as we recover from the pandemic. We are becoming a majo...


Local News

Albert Thomas Jr.

WEATHERCAST

Cold front will chase away storm clouds

By Al Thomas
| April 10, 2021

Warm, humid air and a chance of showers and thunderstorms should be the mainstay for the Wilson Time...

Bailey man wins $100,000 scratch-off prize

For The Enterprise
| April 5, 2021

On a whim, John Bunn of Bailey decided to try his luck on an Extreme Cash ticket and walked away the...

Albert Thomas Jr.

WEATHERCAST

Storm chances to rise later this week

By Al Thomas
| April 5, 2021

Warm temperatures and plenty of sunshine Tuesday and Wednesday in the Wilson Times area will probabl...

Trending recipes