A false, dangerous two-step on Taiwan | The Enterprise
The Enterprise


A false, dangerous two-step on Taiwan

Posted on November 17, 2021


Thomas L. Knapp

Thomas L. Knapp

President Joe Biden and Chinese President Xi Jinping held a “virtual summit” on Monday covering several subjects and resulting, for the most part, in banal public pledges of “cooperation” to “ease tensions.”

Biden, however, managed to score a double own goal on the subject of Taiwan by simultaneously justifying bad U.S. foreign policy and endorsing Beijing’s false “One China” claim.

On one hand, the U.S. has neither any obligation nor any good reason to continue guaranteeing Taiwan’s de facto independence from the mainland regime.

Taiwan is not a U.S. state. Taiwan is not a U.S. territory.  There are no plausible circumstances under which a change of political authority in Taiwan would represent a threat to the defensibility or security of the United States. Therefore the only thing the Taipei regime should expect, or get, from the U.S. regime is a Jeffersonian policy of  “peace, commerce and honest friendship with all nations; entangling alliances with none.”

On the other hand, there’s also no obligation on the part of the U.S. government to pretend that Taipei is part of the People’s Republic of China and subject to the Beijing regime’s authority. It is not, it never has been, and no amount of “One China” posturing on the part of other regimes will change that fact.

Some people paraphrase the question as an answer: “Taiwan has always been part of China.” That’s no more true than the claim that “Cuba has always been part of Spain” or “Ireland has always been part of the United Kingdom.” All three islands have histories preceding their invasion, occupation and colonization, and all three islands have long since established independence (apart from Ireland’s Six Counties, anyway).

Taiwan has, over the last few hundred years, been “part of” the Netherlands, “part of” Qing Dynasty China, “part of” Japan, and finally independent under Chinese nationalists who wanted no part of the mainland’s Communist revolution.

Whether Taiwan ever becomes “part of” the People’s Republic should, in an ideal world, be a decision for its own people to make through whatever institutions they set up to make such decisions.

In our non-ideal world, there’s a good chance that it will become “part of” the People’s Republic through invasion, occupation and colonization. While that would be a bad thing, it’s something the U.S. government should neither commit American blood or treasure to prevent, nor encourage with its “One China” diplomatic balderdash.

Frankly, the latter course seems the likely goal of U.S. strategy. Much as the Carter and Reagan administrations used Afghanistan as bait to give the Soviet Union “its own Vietnam,” the Biden administration may be using Taiwan as bait in hopes of giving Beijing “its own Afghanistan.”

That would be a very bad outcome for all involved — especially the Taiwanese people.

Sooner or later, the U.S. will return to the “hands off foreign disputes” approach that characterized its first century. Better that it do so sooner and voluntarily than later under the compulsion of military, economic and political collapse.

Thomas L. Knapp (Twitter: @thomaslknapp) is director and senior news analyst at the William Lloyd Garrison Center for Libertarian Advocacy Journalism (thegarrisoncenter.org). He lives and works in north central Florida.

More Opinion

Ken Ripley


Waiting for Spring Hope to make things right

By Ken Ripley
| December 6, 2021

One of the issues still not resolved in Spring Hope is the illegal rezoning of 74 acres off N.C. 581...

John Hood


How the spending spree will end

By John Hood
| December 6, 2021

Can I let you in on a not-so-little secret? The Democrats in Washington don’t really mean it. The Re...

DeeAnn Rivera


Legumes in the victory garden

By DeeAnn Rivera
| December 6, 2021

Have you ever needed to leave something familiar to get to someplace better? I have been feeling to...

Local News

Powered by Nash & Pine | v4.2.1